Note any instances where the manuscript has been published elsewhere or submitted to a concurrent journal Call out similarities between this document and other published or unpublished work. TRB strives to publish and present original research.Support your judgment. Review managers and the paper authors should be able to understand your basis for criticism.Keep paper manuscripts confidential. Manuscripts are confidential documents and as such you should avoid discussing the manuscripts or its findings with others.If you feel that you would have any personal bias, recuse yourself from the review process. As TRB uses a single-blind review process, authors are not anonymous. Avoid conflicts of interest. Notify your paper review coordinator if there is any conflict of interest in reviewing a particular paper.Reviews should keep their comments professional and constructive. Objectively review a paper for merit and don’t make the review personal. The paper reviewer should be focused on reviewing a paper for originality, accuracy, and interest to TRB and its committees.Don’t be intimidated by the title give the paper a quick scan to determine if it’s within your area of expertise. Only review a paper if you know enough on a particular topic to successfully review the paper. Determine whether you are qualified to review a paper.These rules help ensure that the review process upholds TRB’s ethical and research standards: Reviewing TRB manuscripts begins with eight simple rules. Here’s some tips to guide you as a paper reviewer: For many of us involved with TRB, paper reviews can seem like a time-consuming chore, however reviews are central to TRB’s mission. Over the next few months TRB staff and committees will pull into high gear to review over three thousand papers to determine suitability for presentation and publishing. As August rolls in, the Transportation Research Board’s paper review season begins.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. Archives
December 2022
Categories |